Jeannette Cutler is an 83-year old woman admitted to hospital after falling and breaking her arm. She reports that she fell because she passed out, and so further investigations are being conducted. She has mild dementia but is otherwise seemingly healthy. Upon admission, she screens positive for MRSA and is subject to strict isolation procedures as per hospital policy.
Jeannette was a long-time volunteer at the hospital where she is now a patient. Jeannette is having trouble adhering to the isolation protocol, and several times a day she gets up and starts going into other patients’ rooms to “visit”. The team has had discussions with her regarding the need for her to remain in her room, but they have failed to achieve the desired effect.
Staff is concerned that she is spreading MRSA and are considering various means of confining her to her room. They aren’t sure how best to express respect for Jeannette while also ensuring that other patients are not unnecessarily exposed to harm. They have contacted the ethics committee and the legal department asking for help in working through this case.
- What ethics concerns are you thinking about as you respond?
- Who should be involved in making this decision?
- What are some competing values that arise in this case?
- Should the well-being of others take precedence over Jeannette’s freedom of mobility?
- What potential creative solutions can you think of to resolve this issue?
Some Values and Ethics Issues to Consider
- Respect for individual liberty
- Patient-centered care
- Distributive justice
- Policy compliance
- Respect for autonomy
- Responsibility for health
- Quality of life
- Respect for dignity
- Beneficence and non-maleficence